The curse of a Super Bowl hangover may be just a superstition, but 49ers fans may be believers after suffering through a brutally injury-plagued season for the second time immediately following a loss in the sport’s season finale. The last time San Francisco missed the playoffs, they finished 6-10 in 2020, following their first loss to the Chiefs in the Super Bowl. After losing to them again this past February, the 49ers currently sit at 5-7, good for last place in the NFC West. 
Going from just missing out on the ultimate prize in football to losing more games than you’re winning is obviously going to create an adverse reaction in fans, but those in the Bay Area are reportedly questioning if head coach Kyle Shanahan‘s seat is beginning to heat up. General manager John Lynch shut down any rumors of that nature today before they could even begin to take root, per Kevin Patra of NFL.com.
“The standard here is to win championships, and we’ve fallen short of that, I understand,” Lynch began, “but we have an excellent head coach, and the fact that people are talking about stuff like that, I do find it comical.”
Lynch points out that, despite the lack of Lombardi trophies, San Francisco has seen unprecedented success under Shanahan. The team has won the NFC West in four of the past five seasons, they’ve played in each of the past three NFC Championship games, and they’ve appeared in two Super Bowls. While disappointment over the current season is warranted, the want for change in the head coaching position may be a bit of an overreaction.
This is especially likely due to the reason the 49ers have experienced losing seasons when they have: injuries. During their 6-10 season, the team saw Nick Mullens make eight starts and C.J. Beathard make two starts when Jimmy Garoppolo‘s 2020 season came to an end after only playing six games. Starting running back Raheem Mostert only got eight games thanks to two stints on injured reserve, forcing starts by Jeff Wilson and Jerick McKinnon. Brandon Aiyuk missed four games, George Kittle missed eight games, and Deebo Samuel missed nine games that year, as well. On defense, ends Nick Bosa and Solomon Thomas missed all but two games, linebacker Kwon Alexander missed 11, and defensive backs Richard Sherman and Jaquiski Tartt missed 11 and nine games, respectively.
This year, Aiyuk suffered a season-ending injury after only seven games, Christian McCaffrey‘s two stints on IR have limited him to only four contests, and even McCaffrey’s surprisingly successful replacement, Jordan Mason, has now been lost for an extended time. On defense, safety Talanoa Hufanga has struggled to return to the field, cornerback Charvarius Ward has missed four games, and defensive tackle Javon Hargrave only played in three games before suffering a season-ending injury. They’ve even had to shuffle special teamers as kicker Jake Moody and punter Mitch Wishnowsky have missed a combined six games.
Lynch understands this better than most, considering it’s been his job to restock at the thinning positions. “I think we’ve been through a lot as a team — this current team — with a lot of stuff that has happened to members of our organization,” Lynch explained. “Injuries, tragic circumstances, ultimately those are just excuses. One thing I can tell you is: I’m proud of how this group has stuck together, had each other’s back. The other thing I can tell you is: the story’s not written yet. We’re still grinding, and we’re still playing.”
He’s not wrong. Despite sitting at 11th in the NFC and last in the West, the 49ers are only two games back of the division-leading Seahawks. Next Gen Stats gives San Francisco a 10 percent chance to make the playoffs and a five percent chance to win the division — long odds, but they’re certainly not dead.
Lastly, an old adage still holds very true: if you’re going to fire a head coach, there should be someone better that you can hire right away. With Shanahan, the situation seems to be the opposite. If the Niners were to part ways with the 44-year-old skipper, any team with an opening (and likely some without a current opening) would be falling over themselves to add him to their staff.
For now, it seems Shanahan is safe. Lynch told the media, “We’re 100 percent behind Kyle and what he brings to our organization.” There doesn’t appear to be any heat on Shanahan’s seat at this time.
I have a timeshare in Arkansas to sell anyone who thinks Lynch has the authority to fire Shanahan
Jags should offer their 1st round pick. Will be top 3, if not #1 overall.
The narrative being put out there by people like Florio that just make up stuff to draw clicks is weak. Florio floated the idea that Shanahan has run his course. The man had his team in OT in the Super Bowl last year. Things have happened this year that no team would overcome. Firing a coach that is always in the biggest games would be a huge mistake. The grass isn’t always greener
The whole “insider” thing is such a racket. They float this kind of BS out there with no accountability when they’re wrong- Which is most of the time.
The problem with trying to shut down rumors is that in many cases all you manage to do is create more speculation and rumors.