Passing on Carson Wentz nine years ago eventually led the Browns to Baker Mayfield. With Mayfield long gone and the player brought in to replace him — Deshaun Watson — on an albatross contract and potentially out for the season, the Browns are still shopping for a veteran.
Kenny Pickett is on Cleveland’s roster, but the team almost definitely needs another option to sell to its fanbase as a Week 1 starter. Although squarely on the radar to draft a passer at No. 2 overall, the Browns hosted Russell Wilson. Giving Wilson another chance to start remains on the Browns’ radar, as they are part of this Aaron Rodgers domino arrangement. The Browns, however, do not appear to be interested in Rodgers.
[RELATED: Wilson Prepared To Sign Deal Amid Rodgers Wait]
The second domino to fall once Rodgers makes his decision — potentially between retirement, the Steelers or the Giants, should the Vikings indeed pass — Wilson appears the Browns’ preference. But the Giants and Steelers are also hovering for the former Pro Bowler. If Wilson passes on the Browns, cleveland.com’s Mary Kay Cabot reports Carson Wentz would become a realistic option. Mutual interest “definitely” exists between the former No. 2 overall pick and the Browns.
Wentz, 32, is obviously far removed from the prospect he was coming out of North Dakota State and has slipped well off the pace from his outlier 2017 season — one that likely would have secured him an MVP had he stayed healthy. The 2024 Chiefs backup was last seen taking the snaps in a 38-0 Kansas City loss to a Denver team playing starters most of the way. But Wentz has plenty of starter experience. He could be a bridge option for the Browns, though this setup would seemingly ramp up the pressure for Cleveland to select a quarterback early in the draft.
As of Sunday, the Browns had not necessarily submitted Wilson an offer, Cabot adds (subscription required). It still appears fairly clear Wilson would be Cleveland’s choice over Wentz, who has not been viewed as a starter since the Commanders benched him late in the 2022 season. Wentz made Week 18 starts with the Rams and Chiefs over the past two years, but he has 94 under his belt as a pro. Certainly not a particularly exciting option at this stage of his career, Wentz looms as an option to join Pickett if Wilson opts for New York or Pittsburgh.
Wentz may not be the next choice for the Browns, however, with Cabot indicating during an appearance on 92.3 The Fan’s Baskin & Phelps (audio link) that a Joe Flacco return remains an option. We heard over the weekend Flacco was back in play with the Browns, who did not submit him an offer to stay — as they made a last-ditch attempt to salvage the Watson sunk cost — last year. Even at 40, Flacco is still drawing interest and appears likely to land a chair as teams scramble for stopgaps.
A plan in which Pickett is the only veteran starter option for the Browns does not appear in play, Cabot adds, though she cautious that money is an object. The Browns have $10MM-plus in cap space, but they obviously still would need to carve out almost that much for their draft class. Kirk Cousins had loomed as an option, but the Falcons are holding onto him as a trade asset.
Cousins, who played for Kevin Stefanski in Minnesota, saw $10MM of his 2026 salary become guaranteed Sunday. But that is subject to offset, meaning the Falcons will hope to bill another team in the event of a trade. The Browns are not in a good position to be taking on that kind of money, as Watson’s guarantees run through 2026. An unfathomable dead money number, thanks to a fourth Watson restructure, would come into play if the Browns cut the wildly disappointing QB next year.
The Giants or Steelers could potentially price Wilson out of Cleveland, especially if a bidding war commences should Rodgers retire. Flacco and Wentz would come cheaper. Ditto Jameis Winston, though Cabot views a Winston return as unlikely. Benched as the Browns careened toward the No. 2 overall pick, Winston left his Giants visit without a deal.
Plenty of teams find themselves in quarterback purgatory. A team with Carson Wentz, Kenny Pickett, and Deshaun Watson under contract in 2025 would be a level of quarterback hell that would make Dante blush.
“Actually, guys, there were supposed to 10 rings. I, uh, I missed one.”
The Browns had the 15th pick in the 2016 draft and Wentz was long gone by then, so how exactly did they take a “pass” on him? Their mistake was taking Cody Kessler with pick 93 when Dak Prescott was still available.
The Browns had the second pick in the draft before they traded down with Philly, who took Wentz.
This. A perfect example of being there, seeing something occur.
Sooo much info out there this week, about the qb carousel , that is conflicting.
Probably because it is 100% driven by agents and team leaks with agendas.
Very little of it passes the common sense test.
I have read that each of the missing teams are all wanting Rogers. I have read that each is not interested in him at all.
For Pitt, The one that got away would be their best fit. Less experience, less resistance, more running ability.
The Browns, I wish articles would stop, each writing a paragraph each time about Pickett.
I don’t see Pickett as relevant in any way.
If he isn’t viewed as a starter, he is not relevant to the qb signing talk. Most every team has a backup, and if they don’t, they will. So what.
Wentz to Cleveland doesn’t even sound that crazy. If not for the rams I think Garapolo would have been signed by now too. This is getting ridiculous. Russ has zero leverage he hasn’t wait for Papa Rodgers to sign before he makes a choice lol
I’d love to see them sign Russell Wilson so Kenny can compete with him for the starter’s job.
There’s evidence to suggest that Kenny might not be too jazzed about it, but…
Can MKC be replaced? Please?