Bills To Fire ST Coordinator Matthew Smiley

In the wake of their season-ending in the AFC title game, Bills head coach Sean McDermott offered a vote of confidence in special teams coordinator Matthew Smiley. Buffalo will nevertheless be making a change on the sidelines.

The Bills are parting ways with Smiley, as first reported by NFL Network’s Tom Pelissero. That represents a notable about-face on McDermott’s part, considering his remarks at the end of the campaign. Smiley had severed as special teams coordinator for the past three seasons.

“Matthew has done a nice job,” McDermott said at his season-ending press conference (via ESPN’s Alaina Getzenberg). “Listen, I know there are plays that have come up, and I know he doesn’t feel great about them, nor do I. Those are learning pieces for a coach in his position… All that being said, I’m confident that Coach Smiley is going to learn from those situations and plays that came up this year.”

In spite of that sentiment, Buffalo will make a move in the third phase for 2025. Smiley’s unit was affected by the many defensive injuries the Bills dealt with early in the year in particular, but it still fell short of expectations. Personnel issues were a consistent problem in 2024, a year in which the team allowed a punt block return and a kick return touchdown. Overall, Buffalo’s 30.8 kick return yards allowed on average was the fifth-worst mark in the league.

Smiley, 46, first joined the Bills in 2017 as a special teams assistant. He previously worked in that capacity with the Jaguars from 2013-16 after working as a special teams coordinator on two occasions at the college level. He will now look to find his next opportunity late in the 2025 hiring cycle as McDermott and the Bills seek out a replacement capable of leading a more consistent showing on special teams moving forward.