With Mike McCarthy a coaching free agent after he and the Cowboys did not reach serious negotiations on a new deal, the Bears are back in play. And they will meet with the five-year Cowboys leader.
McCarthy will interview for the Chicago HC job Wednesday, the Dallas Morning News’ David Moore reports. The Bears had requested a McCarthy meeting while he was still under contract, but the Cowboys blocked it. That is no longer in the equation, and the Bears will take advantage.
It’s rare to see an organization request a HC interview with another team’s head coach, although perhaps the Bears were reading the tea leafs ahead of the Dallas divorce. Chicago’s request also revealed that the front office would be willing to consider a trade for a head coach. Of course, that route seemed unlikely with Dallas considering the coach’s expiring contract, and now the Bears won’t face any restrictions as they consider McCarthy for their head coaching vacancy.
The Bears have left no stone unturned in their search for a new head coach, with the team’s long list of candidates only rivaling the Jets during this year’s hiring cycle. McCarthy would naturally represent one of the more experienced names on the list, although the Bears haven’t really hinted at whether they’re seeking a veteran coach or a fresh face. The team’s search has ranged from the likes of long-time coach Pete Carroll to Notre Dame’s Marcus Freeman, who doesn’t have any NFL experience.
Considering McCarthy’s penchant for developing quarterbacks, it’s not a surprise that the Bears would consider the long-time coach as they look to maximize first-overall pick Caleb Williams. McCarthy, of course, helped oversee the Packers’ transition from Brett Favre to Aaron Rodgers, and he finished his 13-year Green Bay tenure with only three losing seasons.
Dak Prescott was already well established when McCarthy was installed as the Cowboys’ head coach, and there was hope that the fresh voice could help guide Dallas to the promised land. That obviously didn’t come to fruition, and McCarthy started gaining a reputation as a playoff failure. For a Bears team that’s simply looking to regain some credibility, that sentiment probably won’t be a major concern.
McCarthy is the 20th name connected to the Bears head coaching vacancy. Per our 2025 NFL Head Coaching Search Tracker, the rest of that group includes:
- Bill Belichick, head coach (North Carolina): Expressed interest
- Joe Brady, offensive coordinator (Bills): Interview requested
- Thomas Brown, interim head coach (Bears): Interviewed 1/13
- Matt Campbell, head coach (Iowa State): Interview expected
- Pete Carroll, former head coach (Seahawks): Interviewed 1/9
- Brian Flores, defensive coordinator (Vikings): Interview requested
- Marcus Freeman, head coach (Notre Dame): Team wants to interview
- Aaron Glenn, defensive coordinator (Lions): Interviewed 1/11
- Ben Johnson, offensive coordinator (Lions): Interviewed 1/11
- Mike Kafka, offensive coordinator (Giants): Interviewed 1/9
- Kliff Kingsbury, offensive coordinator (Commanders): Interview requested
- Todd Monken, offensive coordinator (Ravens): Interview requested
- Drew Petzing, offensive coordinator (Cardinals): Interviewed 1/8
- Ron Rivera, former head coach (Commanders): Interviewed 1/12
- David Shaw, senior personnel executive (Broncos): Interview requested
- Arthur Smith, offensive coordinator (Steelers): Interview requested
- Adam Stenavich, offensive coordinator (Packers): Interview requested
- Mike Vrabel, former head coach (Titans): Interviewed 1/8; hired by Patriots
- Anthony Weaver, defensive coordinator (Dolphins): Interviewed 1/9
Just so Bears like.
I know the Bears have felt burned on some first time head coaches, but imagine signing up to definitely have the worst coach in the division. I guess in many ways McCarthy can provide a stable voice for Williams, and developing Williams is the most important thing for the franchise, but McCarthy’s scheme is also kind of outdated and in Dallas has asked Dak to do way more than you would want a second year QB taking on, like calling out protections.
That division has 3 playoff teams, with 1 being a SB contender. Not so bad to be the “worst” HC who has an excellent NFL W/L record and a SB ring. McCarthy is certainly more qualified than most of the other 20 candidates they’re interviewing.
I would like to see Freeman but I don’t think he’ll leave ND for Chicago’s managerial – ownership mess!
You get the feeling the bears are trying to make themselves seem like a desirable job destination by interviewing as many people as they are but they’re really trying to just impress like 1 or 2 candidates who are on the fence about accepting the job?
No problem with meeting McCarthy. But the overall number of candidates being considered is over the top. It’s leading to paralysis by over analysis. There’s at least 8 candidates I would personally not waste my time. That’s just me. If you haven’t read “Blink: The Power of Thinking Without Thinking” by Malcolm Gladwell, I highly recommend it. Maybe check it out during these cold winter days. The book dissects examples of how leaders, CEOs and individuals make difficult and consequential decisions. Gladwell eloquently points out that having too much information can actually be bad. In fact, Gladwell determines that the best decision-makers usually produce the right choice quickly with only smaller amounts of pertinent data points because it eliminates the possibility of overthinking and over analyzing.
OK, but what if instead of the best decision-makers, it’s the Chicago Bears making the decision?
Literally no reason not to seek out as many opinions and ideas as possible from as many qualified people as are willing to give them to you for free.
And FWIW, if the “best decision-makers” are overwhelmed by having to weigh a large number of choices and options, they are, in fact, NOT the best decision-makers. They are the people who just happened to make it and got interviewed later.
Literally no reason not to seek out as many opinions and ideas as possible from as many qualified people as are willing to give them to you for free.
You can ask coaching candidates, current/former/head coaches, current/former GM’s, the sports media and fans for their options and ideas and they’ll all say fix the O-Line and D-Line. Absolutely nothing hard for the Bears to figure out.
What are you looking for in 20 candidates? Who will take the least amount of money? They are clueless.
20 people and they’ll still get it wrong.
All that’s left is the Pope and Biden. After that we start with Soccer Coaches.
I know a lot of people are getting all bent out of shape at the number of candidates that the Bears are brining in. However, last time the Bears did this, they had like 3 candidates. At least you can’t say Poles isn’t trying. The other thing is that it’s not like you can hire or even make an announcement that you want someone like Ben Johnson since he’s still on an active team. Sure they can make an under the table hand shake, but if you stop the process, it’s will look suspicious.
There have been 17 attempts by SB winning coaches to duplicate the accomplishment with a second team and none of those attempts have succeeded. For that reason alone I’d take a pass on McCarthy.
VINCE LOMBARDI – WASHINGTON 1969
HANK STRAM – NEW ORLEANS 1976
DON MCCAFFERTY – DETROIT 1973
TOM FLORES – SEATTLE 1992-94
MIKE DITKA – NEW ORLEANS 1997-99
BILL PARCELLS – NEW ENGLAND 1993-96
– NY JETS 1997-99
– DALLAS 2004-2006
GEORGE SEIFERT – CAROLINA 1999-2001
JIMMY JOHNSON – MIAMI 1996-1999
MIKE HOLMGREM – SEATTLE 1999-2008
MIKE SHANAHAN – WASHINGTON 2010-13
DICK VERMEIL – KANSAS CITY 2001-05
JON GRUDEN – RAIDERS 2018-2021
SEAN PAYTON – DENVER 2023-
MIKE MCCARTHY – DALLAS 2020-2024
DOUG PEDERSON – JACKSONVILLE 2022-24