Steelers’ James Daniels Suffers Achilles Tear

Coming into Week 4 with significant injury trouble along their offensive line, the Steelers exited their season’s first defeat worse off. James Daniels is not expected to play again this season.

The veteran guard suffered an Achilles tear during Pittsburgh’s loss to Indianapolis, ESPN.com’s Jeremy Fowler tweets. Daniels, who is not signed beyond this season, joins first-round rookie Troy Fautanu in being set to miss the regular season. While Fautanu’s absence is not certain to shut him down if the Steelers make the playoffs, Daniels should not be considered an IR-return candidate regardless of how far the team’s season lasts.

Pittsburgh has already played without its other guard starter — Isaac Seumalo — throughout the season. The ex-Eagle is expected to return soon, as he is not on IR, but the team’s initial starting center — Nate Herbig — is on IR due to a torn rotator cuff sustained during the preseason. The Steelers placed Herbig on IR without a preseason return designation, ending his season. Daniels’ injury adds to a burgeoning crisis for the 3-1 team up front.

This is a brutal blow for Daniels, who exited the Steelers’ Week 4 loss as Pro Football Focus’ top-ranked guard. The former Bears second-round pick, based on where this year’s guard market went, was poised to cash in on a lucrative third contract. The Steelers, who do not negotiate in-season, did not extend Daniels this offseason. While the team holds exclusive negotiating rights with the Iowa alum until the 2025 legal tampering period, Daniels’ price probably drops — perhaps significantly — due to this setback.

Daniels, 27, is attached to a three-year deal worth $27MM signed in 2022. He joined center Mason Cole as free agency imports brought in that year, as the Steelers planned to select Ben Roethlisberger‘s heir apparent and equip him with veteran O-linemen. The Kenny Pickett plan failed, and the team made Cole a cap casualty early this offseason. But Daniels remained in Pittsburgh’s designs. He had missed just two games with the team from 2022-23.

While Daniels had loomed as a potential offseason extension recipient, the seventh-year blocker subsequently confirmed the Steelers were not planning to pay him this year. The team does not field a particularly pricey O-line, with no eight-figure-per-year contracts up front, and is paying low-level money to its two quarterbacks of note. But Daniels still entered the season without an extension. Now, his future is a bit cloudy.

Pittsburgh has used 2023 seventh-round pick Spencer Anderson in place of Semualo to start the season; the 2023 free agency pickup has missed time with a pectoral injury sustained shortly before the season. Semualo is not on IR but has already missed four games. A weekend report also indicated the ex-Eagle was not quite ready to return, pointing to a potential Anderson-Mason McCormick guard duo — around rookie center Zach Frazier — in Week 5.

The Steelers chose McCormick in Round 4 this year. McCormick already usurped Anderson for the starting LG gig in Week 4, with the duo in line to platoon to open the game. PFF grades Anderson as the NFL’s fifth-worst guard, among qualified options. Seumalo’s debut could restore this platoono; until then, the Steelers will be forced to go young at guard on an O-line that already features second-year tackle Broderick Jones.