Tuesday marked the deadline for teams to decide on fifth-year options. The NFL’s annual round of choices regarding rookie-contract bumps moved a large number of players into contract years.
A few players were not eligible to see their options picked up, due to teams already cutting ties. The Raiders waived both their 2020 first-rounders — Henry Ruggs and Damon Arnette — following off-field events. The Titans bailed on tackle Isaiah Wilson after one season and four career snaps. Former Vikings draftee Jeff Gladney tragically died in a car accident last year, weeks after the Cardinals had signed him. Because the Falcons restructured Jeff Okudah‘s contract, Michael Rothstein of ESPN.com notes (via Twitter) the former No. 3 overall pick is ineligible for the fifth-year option.
The 2020 first round housed Joe Burrow, Justin Herbert and Tua Tagovailoa, along with standout receivers Justin Jefferson and CeeDee Lamb. A few left tackle anchors came off the board as well. In addition to the likes of Roger Goodell‘s recliner and Bill Belichick‘s dog, the 2020 first round will be remembered for misfires. Only 12 fifth-year options ended up being exercised. Seventeen (the class of 2016) marked the previous low, Albert Breer of SI.com notes (on Twitter). Twenty-three (2014) remains the record for most options picked up.
A few factors contribute to this low total. While the 2020 Scouting Combine took place, the COVID-19 pandemic nixed most pre-draft visits and shut down in-person workouts and meetings. The virtual draft led to some missteps, particularly in the second half of Round 1. But the CBA agreed to weeks earlier in 2020 changed the option structure. Fifth-year options — guaranteed for injury only as part of the 2011 CBA — became fully guaranteed in 2020. This helped prevent teams from picking up a player’s option, thus delaying agency, and cutting him a year later if he passed a physical. This change introduces more risk with option calls.
Still, the 2018 first-round contingent — the first to see their options come with full guarantees — produced 21 exercised options and one option-negating extension (the Raiders’ Kolton Miller). The 2019 class produced 19. The Packers reached an extension agreement with Jordan Love earlier today, though it is not a traditional re-up like Miller’s. Love’s fully guaranteed money ($13.5MM) compared to what it would have cost the team to pick up the option ($20.27MM).
Via PFR’s fifth-year option tracker, here is how teams proceeded with 2020 first-rounders’ 2024 options:
- QB Joe Burrow, Bengals ($29.5MM): Exercised
- DE Chase Young, Commanders ($17.45MM): Declined
- CB Jeff Okudah, Falcons* ($11.51MM): N/A
- T Andrew Thomas, Giants ($14.18MM): Exercised
- QB Tua Tagovailoa, Dolphins ($23.2MM): Exercised
- QB Justin Herbert, Chargers ($29.5MM): Exercised
- DT Derrick Brown, Panthers ($11.67MM): Exercised
- LB Isaiah Simmons, Cardinals ($12.72MM): Declined
- CB C.J. Henderson, Jaguars** ($11.51MM): Declined
- T Jedrick Wills, Browns ($14.18MM): Exercised
- T Mekhi Becton, Jets ($12.57MM): Declined
- WR Henry Ruggs, Raiders: N/A
- T Tristan Wirfs, Buccaneers ($18.24MM): Exercised
- DT Javon Kinlaw, 49ers ($10.46MM): Declined
- WR Jerry Jeudy, Broncos ($14.12MM): Exercised
- CB AJ Terrell, Falcons ($12.34MM): Exercised
- WR CeeDee Lamb, Cowboys ($17.99MM): Exercised
- OL Austin Jackson, Dolphins ($14.18MM): Declined
- CB Damon Arnette, Raiders: N/A
- DE K’Lavon Chaisson, Jaguars ($12.14MM): Declined
- WR Jalen Reagor, Vikings*** ($12.99MM): Declined
- WR Justin Jefferson, Vikings ($19.74MM): Exercised
- LB Kenneth Murray, Chargers ($11.73MM): Declined
- G Cesar Ruiz, Saints ($14.18MM): Declined
- WR Brandon Aiyuk, 49ers ($14.12MM): Exercised
- QB Jordan Love, Packers ($20.27MM): Extended through 2024
- LB Jordyn Brooks, Seahawks ($12.72MM): Declined
- LB Patrick Queen, Ravens ($12.72MM): Declined
- T Isaiah Wilson, Titans: N/A
- CB Noah Igbinoghene, Dolphins ($11.51MM): Declined
- CB Jeff Gladney, Vikings: N/A
- RB Clyde Edwards-Helaire, Chiefs ($5.46MM): Declined
* = Lions traded Okudah on April 11, 2023
** = Jaguars traded Henderson on Sept. 27, 2021
*** = Eagles traded Reagor on August 31, 2022
I understand why the N/A for players out of the league. Not sure why Okudah was an N/A.
Part of the restructuring they did with his contract
He was traded and signed an extension. His fifth year option is voided when he signed a new deal, so the team did not have to decide to pick up the option or not. N/A.
I wonder if that draft class also set a record for 1st round picks that are no longer in the league.