Tom Brady

Roger Goodell To Hear Tom Brady’s Appeal

9:32pm: The NFL has released a statement confirming that Goodell will hear the appeal, as Mike Garafolo of FOX Sports tweets. The statement indicates that NFL executive vice president Troy Vincent was the one who determined the punishment with Goodell being the one to “authorize” it.

9:15pm: Commissioner Roger Goodell will hear Tom Brady‘s appeal, according to Mike Freeman of Bleacher Report (on Twitter). Earlier today, the NFLPA formally filed its appeal on behalf of Brady and asked for a neutral arbitrator to preside over the case. Needless to say, this isn’t exactly what they had in mind.

The collective bargaining agreement, signed in 2011, allows the league’s commissioner to oversee appeals. Goodell could have vacated that position, but he will invoke his right to rule on the appeal.

Brady has armed himself with a top notch legal team that includes labor attorney Jeffrey Kessler, who recently represented Adrian Peterson in his suspension appeal. The Patriots, meanwhile, also seem ready to go to war with the league office. The franchise’s legal counsel published a rebuttal to the Wells report earlier today that is nearly 20,000 words long.

NFLPA Appeals Tom Brady’s Suspension

The NFL Players Association has formally filed its appeal on behalf of Tom Brady, in an effort to reduce or eliminate the quarterback’s four-game suspension, the union announced today. The NFLPA’s statement includes a request for a neutral arbitrator, citing the NFL’s “history of inconsistency and arbitrary decisions in disciplinary matters.”

If Ted Wells and the NFL believe, as their public comments stated, that the evidence in their report is ‘direct’ and ‘inculpatory,’ then they should be confident enough to present their case before someone who is truly independent,” the statement reads.

There was previously some question over whether Brady would enlist the help of the NFLPA in his battle, but it appears that the two sides have joined forces and they’re apparently willing to make things messy. Brady has had a rocky relationship with the union ever since he was listed as the named plaintiff in the lawsuit against the NFL during the 2011 lockout. The quarterback is pulling out all stops as he has also hired Jeffrey Kessler, the attorney whose legal action helped create free agency in the NFL.

Brady’s agent Don Yee went on the offensive and heavily criticized the findings of Wells’ report earlier this week, but Wells fired back the next day against what he felt was an attack on his impartiality. All things considered, it sounds like things could get ugly between Brady’s side and the league office.

Zach Links contributed to this post.

Latest On Brady, Kraft, Patriots

Tom Brady and his camp have until 11:00pm CT on Thursday to officially file an appeal in response to his four-game suspension, and we have a handful of updates on that appeal process in the space below. Here’s the latest on Brady and DeflateGate:

  • As one Tuesday report outlined, there was some uncertainty about whether Brady and agent Don Yee would involve the NFLPA in their appeal of the quarterback’s four-game ban, but Ed Werder of ESPN.com tweets that Brady’s camp has finally involved the union in the process. The Players Association is expected to take the lead in Brady’s appeal, says Werder.
  • As Barry Wilner of The Associated Press outlines, labor attorney Jeffrey Kessler, who recently represented Adrian Peterson in his suspension appeal, will aid the NFLPA in Brady’s appeal.
  • The NFLPA has already drafted Brady’s appeal letter, but it’s still going through the union’s process and will likely be formally filed tomorrow, tweets Albert Breer of the NFL Network.
  • At least one source tells ESPN’s Adam Schefter that he thinks Brady’s “talented, big-name lawyers,” including Kessler, will get the penalty overturned and that the quarterback won’t miss a game. Schefter conveyed that source’s message on The Herd With Colin Cowherd” today, and also suggested that the Patriots are “angry” about the penalties handed down by the NFL (including lost draft picks and a $1MM fine), since the organization doesn’t feel as if it did anything wrong. Doug Kyed of NESN.com has the details, along with quotes from Schefter.
  • Jason La Canfora of CBSSports.com agrees with Schefter’s assessment of the Pats’ reaction to the NFL’s decision, writing that the team is “fuming.” Although owner Robert Kraft and the franchise hadn’t initially been planning to fight the discipline handed down by the league, the overall scope of that discipline “was unlike anything they expected,” a source tells La Canfora. Per La Canfora, Kraft and his team may challenge the NFL’s ruling, but that’s probably still a long shot at this point.
  • Multiple sources tell Jason Cole of Bleacher Report (video link) that Kraft is “strongly considering” filing a lawsuit against the NFL over the ruling. However, according to Cole, many of those same sources are trying to discourage the Pats owner from doing so, since they believe it will be a “fruitless endeavor.”

AFC East Notes: Brady, Pats, Dolphins

Here’s a quick look at the Patriots and Dolphins

  • It’ll be interesting to see whether Patriots quarterback Tom Brady enlists the help of the NFLPA to try and reduce his suspension, says Jason Cole of Bleacher Report (video link). It might seem like a slam dunk that the quarterback would use the union given their successful history in this department, but Cole hears that Brady is distrustful of the NFLPA ever since he was the named plaintiff in the lawsuit against the NFL during the 2011 lockout.
  • Jeffrey Kessler, the attorney whose legal action helped create free agency in the NFL, has been added to Brady’s legal team, according to Andrew Brandt of ESPN (on Twitter). Brandt expects that Kessler will handle the Patriots star’s appeal.
  • Dolphins fourth round rookie Jamil Douglas is determined to be in the starting lineup this year, James Walker of ESPN.com writes. “There’s definitely a sense of urgency,” Douglas said of his mindset. “That would be regardless of whether they needed it or not. I want to contribute to this team as much as possible and help this team win games. So there’s definitely a sense of urgency from me.” Dallas Thomas and Billy Turner are the two early favorites at left and right guard, respectively, but Douglas has plenty of experience with 40 career starts in college.
  • Ted Wells Responds To Tom Brady’s Agent

    Hours after the NFL levied sanctions against Tom Brady and the Patriots for their alleged role in the doctoring of footballs, Brady’s agent Don Yee went on the offensive and heavily criticized the findings of Ted Wells’ report. This afternoon, Wells held a conference call with reporters to offer his rebuttal to Yee’s comments. Here are some of the highlights from what proved to be an entertaining Q&A session..

    • Wells said that no one from Brady’s camp raised any issue with his impartiality and noted that owner Bob Kraft welcomed his appointment, Ian Rapoport of NFL.com tweets.
    • The team led by Wells only asked Brady for printouts of his text messages and not for his actual phone, Mike Freeman of Bleacher Report tweets. This is an important distinction because the quarterback cited privacy concerns with regard to handing over his phone.
    • Outside of that, Brady was “totally cooperative” in the investigation, Wells said, according to SiriusXM NFL Radio (on Twitter).
    • Wells said the Pats declined his request for a second interview with Jim McNally (per SiriusXM NFL Radio on Twitter). The second interview was requested, and denied, after Wells discovered the now famed “Deflator” text, Ben Volin of the Boston Globe tweets. Wells said NFL security talked with McNally three times, but he only personally interviewed him once, Jason La Canfora of CBSSports.com tweets.
    • Wells strongly rejected the notion that the text messages are circumstantial evidence, Albert Breer of NFL.com tweets.
    • Yee says that he took copious notes throughout the questioning of his client and Wells says he has no issue with the agent publishing those notes, Rapoport tweets.
    • The investigator rejected the notion that his fact finding mission was a “sting operation,” Armando Salguero of the Miami Herald tweets.
    • NFL executive VP Jeff Pash, whom the league tabbed to co-lead the investigation, was just “a facilitator” and didn’t participate in interviews, according to Wells (via Tom Pelissero of USA Today on Twitter).
    • The investigation cost the NFL “millions,” Wells said, according to Ben Volin of the Boston Globe (on Twitter).

    Latest On Patriots, Tom Brady

    On Monday night, Patriots owner Robert Kraft (via Twitter) issued a statement regarding the penalties levied against his team.

    Despite our conviction that there was no tampering with footballs, it was our intention to accept any discipline levied by the league. Today’s punishment, however, far exceeded any reasonable expectation. It was based completely on circumstantial rather than hard or conclusive evidence. We are humbled by the support the New England Patriots have received from our fans throughout the world. We recognize our fans’ concerns regarding the NFL’s penalties and share in their disappointment in how this one-sided investigation was handled, as well as the dismissal of the scientific evidence supported by the Ideal Gas Law in the final report. Tom Brady has our unconditional support. Our belief in him has not wavered.”

    Kraft’s statement made it clear that he is standing shoulder-to-shoulder with Brady, who is also prepared to fight the league. Here’s another round of reactions to the Pats’ scandal..

    • Jason La Canfora of CBSSports.com (on Twitter) wouldn’t expect the Patriots to be in the market right away for a veteran quarterback in the wake of the Brady ruling. He believes that the Pats will wait to see how the appeal goes and evaluate their own situation before making any moves. As it stands, rising sophomore Jimmy Garoppolo would likely be New England’s starter for the first four games of the 2015 season.
    • An NFL owner told Mike Freeman of Bleacher Report (on Twitter) that the relationship between commissioner Roger Goodell and Kraft seems “pretty much dead.” “I can’t say for certain but it sure seems that way to me,” the owner, who knows both men well, said. “Some of us (owners) are waiting a little nervously to see what Robert does next.”
    • Mike Chappell of CBS4 (on Twitter) wouldn’t be surprised if Brady appeals and has his four-game suspension cut in half.
    • The $1MM fine levied against the Patriots is the largest team fine in NFL history, according to Adam Schefter of ESPN (via SportsCenter on Twitter).
    • Brady’s agent, Don Yee, is going to the mat for his client as they prepare to appeal his suspension. Yee also represents Saints coach Sean Payton, and Larry Holder of The Times-Picayune wonders why Yee didn’t fight harder for him when he was suspended for a season as a result of BountyGate.
    • Brady left Roger Goodell no choice but to make an example of him, Mike Lupica of the New York Daily News opines.
    • Rick Gosselin of The Dallas Morning News explained why the punishment for the Patriots and Brady was so severe.

    Tom Brady To Appeal Suspension

    Tom Brady‘s agent issued a statement to reporters stating, in part, that the quarterback will appeal the suspension handed to him earlier today. Here is the statement in its entirety, courtesy of ESPN.com’s Adam Schefter (via Facebook):

    The discipline is ridiculous and has no legitimate basis. In my opinion, this outcome was pre-determined; there was no fairness in the Wells investigation whatsoever. There is no evidence that Tom directed footballs be set at pressures below the allowable limits.

    In fact, the evidence shows Tom clearly emphasized that footballs be set at pressures within the rules. Tom also cooperated with the investigation and answered every question presented to him. The Wells Report presents significant evidence, however, that the NFL lacks standards or protocols with respect to its handling of footballs prior to games; this is not the fault of Tom or the Patriots.

    The report also presents significant evidence the NFL participated with the Colts in some type of pre-AFC Championship Game planning regarding the footballs. This fact may raise serious questions about the integrity of the games we view on Sundays. We will appeal, and if the hearing officer is completely independent and neutral, I am very confident the Wells Report will be exposed as an incredibly frail exercise in fact-finding and logic.

    The NFL has a well-documented history of making poor disciplinary decisions that often are overturned when truly independent and neutral judges or arbitrators preside, and a former federal judge has found the commissioner has abused his discretion in the past, so this outcome does not surprise me. Sadly, today’s decision diminishes the NFL as it tells its fans, players and coaches that the games on the field don’t count as much as the games played on Park Avenue.”

    The news, of course, does not come as a great surprise. Brady is well within his rights to appeal the decision and cannot be punished further for presenting his case. With the help of the NFLPA, Brady will likely cite the lack of hard evidence against him as a primary reason why he should have the suspension lowered or rescinded. Brady could also cite precedent as a reason why he is being penalized to harshly.

    Prior to the suspension being announced, Albert Breer of NFL.com (on Twitter) noted that Saints defensive lineman Anthony Hargrove was suspended eight games for his obstruction in Bountygate, but he later had that penalty reduced to two games. Because of that, Breer had estimated a two-game suspension for Brady. After an appeal, Brady could very well wind up serving less than a four-game suspension.

    Reactions To Punishment For Pats, Brady

    In the latest sign that this really is a “new” NFL, the Patriots were hit with major penalties for their apparent involvement in deflating footballs during the playoffs. Quarterback Tom Brady, who seemed to be less than cooperative in helping with the NFL’s investigation, was sacked with a four game suspension. In addition to that, the Pats were stripped of their 2016 first-round draft pick as well as their fourth-round selection in the 2017 NFL Draft. Here’s a look at some of the reaction and fallout to the NFL’s surprisingly stern decision..

    • Brady was scheduled to make $8MM this season and, as a result, will lose about $2MM thanks to the suspension, Adam Schefter of ESPN.com tweets.
    • Any action by the NFLPA will be at the direction of Brady, so they’ll wait for instructions from him, Albert Breer of NFL.com (on Twitter) notes.
    • Goodell may have lost Bob Kraft as an ally today, but he isn’t going anywhere, Adam Beasley of the Miami Herald tweets. Beasley posits that he couldn’t have made such a bold move without gauging the support of the league’s 31 other owners.
    • At this point, the Bills are the only AFC East team that will directly benefit from Brady’s suspension, Armando Salguero of the Miami Herald tweets. The Bills now only face Brady once while the Dolphins and Jets have to deal with him twice.
    • Giants quarterback Eli Manning told reporters, including Paul Schwartz of the New York Post (on Twitter) that he is “in no way…glad to see this happen.” However, he added that, “If someone’s breaking the rules I understand you’re gonna get punished for it,” (link).
    • The cynic in Beasley (link) wonders if the NFL waited until after this year’s draft since the Pats will probably be picking higher than No. 32 next year.

    Tom Brady Handed Four Game Suspension

    The NFL announced that Patriots quarterback Tom Brady has been suspended for four games for his involvement in the DeflateGate scandal, as Mike Garafolo of FOX Sports tweets. The Patriots have also been stripped of their first-round pick in 2016 and fined $1MM, Adam Beasley of the Miami Herald (on Twitter) adds. The Pats will also lose the fourth-round selection in the 2017 NFL Draft, Ian Rapoport of NFL.com tweets. Tom Brady (vertical)

    Jason Wilde of ESPN.com (on Twitter) passes along the full statement. It reads, in part:

    The New England Patriots were notified today of the following discipline that has been imposed for violations of the NFL Policy on Integrity of the Game and Enforcement of Competitive Rules relating to the use of under-inflated footballs in the AFC Championship Game of this past season:

    For the violation of the playing rules and the failure to cooperate in the subsequent investigation, the New England Patriots are fined $1 million and will forfeit the club’s first-round selection in the 2016 NFL Draft and the club’s fourth-round selection in the 2017 NFL Draft. If the Patriots have more than one selection in either of these rounds, the earlier selection shall be forfeited. The club may not trade or otherwise encumber these selections.

    Patriots owner Robert Kraft advised Commissioner Roger Goodell last week that Patriots employees John Jastremski and James McNally have been indefinitely suspended without pay by the club, effective on May 6th. Neither of these individuals may be reinstated without the prior approval of NFL Executive Vice President of Football Operations Troy Vincent. If they are reinstated by the Patriots, Jastremski is prohibited from having any role in the preparation, supervision, or handling of footballs to be used in NFL games during the 2015 season. McNally is barred from serving as a locker room attendant for the game officials, or having any involvement with the preparation, supervision, or handling of footballs or any other equipment on game day.

    Quarterback Tom Brady will be suspended without pay for the first four games of the 2015 regular season for conduct detrimental to the integrity of the NFL. Brady may participate in all off-season, training camp and pre-season activities, including pre-season games.

    Commissioner Goodell authorized the discipline that was imposed by NFL Executive President Troy Vincent, pursuant to the commissioner’s disciplinary authority under the NFL Constitution and Bylaws and the Collective Bargaining Agreement with the NFL Players Association.

    We reached these decisions after extensive discussion with Troy Vincent and many others,” Commissioner Goodell said. “We relied on the critical importance of protecting the integrity of the game and the thoroughness and independence of the Wells report.”

    The letter also notes that there was no evidence found to prove that head coach Bill Belichick or any Patriots’ staff member besides Jastremski and McNally took part in the deflating of footballs. One has to imagine that the Patriots will be quick to cite that as they dispute the penalties levied against them.

    The NFL also made Vincent’s letter to Brady available to reporters (including Shalise Manza Young of the Boston Globe on Twitter) and his words are rather scathing. He reprimands Brady for his failure to cooperate in full with the NFL’s investigation and calls his conduct “detrimental to the integrity” of the game. Vincent adds that “While [the evidence] cannot be certain when the activity began, evidence suggests that 1/18 was not the first and only occasion.” The league’s Executive Vice President of Football Operations also referred back to the SpyGate scandal to illustrate that the organization has a history of misconduct.

    The suspension of Brady ostensibly leaves backup Jimmy Garoppolo as the team’s starter for the first month of the season. The 23-year-old (24 in November) completed 19 of 27 passes in his rookie season.

    Photo courtesy of USA Today Sports Images.

    Tom Brady Suspension Coming Next Week?

    Roger Goodell is expected to suspend Tom Brady next week, sources informed Gary Myers of the New York Daily News.

    Sources close to Goodell have little doubt the commissioner is viewing DeflateGate as a “serious violation,” which will prompt, in Myers’ view, the highest-profile player suspended in the NFL’s 96 years. The Patriots are bracing for a suspension of Brady that could last as long as eight games, according to CSNNE.com’s Mike Girardi.

    After the 37-year-old Brady landed as the notable figure in this week’s DeflateGate report, the Pats are preparing for what would be a startling suspension for a player of Brady’s caliber and one that could define defending Super Bowl champions’ season. Pundits and sources around the league have the potential Brady-less portion of the Pats season hovering between two and 16 games.

    Myers does think the commissioner will be more lenient that Girardi’s report would lead you to believe, with a two-game suspension expected after possibly an appeal-induced reduction from four. But the Daily News reporter adds that the sources believe there is enough, between Brady’s alleged ordering of footballs to be deflated and lack of cooperation with Wells’ investigation by not turning over his cell phone, to warrant a suspension.

    Myers’ sources said previous reports of a 16-game suspension are “way off,” however.

    In the time span that appears to be the floor of a potential Brady suspension, the Patriots open the season with a home tilt against the Steelers before traveling to face the Bills. Jimmy Garoppolo enters his second year after having completed 19-of-27 passes as a rookie exclusively during inconsequential sequences. New England finished 11-5 in 2008, its last season that featured games without Brady’s services.