OCTOBER 26: The Dolphins have officially made the move to activate Tagovailoa from IR. After clearing concussion protocol, the oft-injured quarterback will attempt to prove the doubters wrong by trying to show that he was right not to retire.
In a corresponding move, Miami made room for Tagovailoa on the 53-man roster by releasing veteran backup Tim Boyle. Additionally, the team made the announcement that defensive tackle Neil Farrell and long snapper Matt Overton would serve as the Dolphins’ standard gameday practice squad elevations tomorrow.
OCTOBER 25: Tua Tagovailoa‘s anticipated Week 8 return is a go. The Dolphins quarterback has cleared concussion protocol and will start against the Cardinals on Sunday, NFL.com’s Cameron Wolfe tweets. Mike McDaniel confirmed the clearance.
Miami will activate Tagovailoa from IR before Saturday afternoon’s deadline. While the QB’s concussion history will continue to generate scrutiny, Tua did not consider retirement after his latest head injury — sustained back in Week 2.
Consulting doctors across the country, Tagovailoa received good news regarding his NFL future. None of the doctors recommended he retire, McDaniel said. That said, ESPN.com’s Marcel Louis-Jacques and the Miami Herald’s Barry Jackson note the high bar for doctors to recommend retirement. Two neurologists informed Jackson a future Tagovailoa concussion should prompt a lengthy absence.
In accordance with the NFL’s protocol, an independent neurologist cleared Tagovailoa after Miami’s Thursday practice. Tua will be back after missing the minimum four games, though even that absence qualified as notable since teams generally do not place players on IR because of concussions.
Tagovailoa, 26, is a special case due to his high profile and injury past. Tua sustained two confirmed concussions in 2022 and most likely suffered three, with a Week 3 injury that season leading to the NFL revamping its concussion protocol. The Miami QB returned to action in that Bills matchup but suffered a concussion against the Bengals four days later. That led to a two-game absence. When Tua was concussed again during a Christmas Day game, he missed the rest of the Dolphins’ season. Despite the left-handed passer returning in 2023 and not missing any time, his latest head injury has naturally brought tremendous concern about his future.
The Dolphins gave their top quarterback a four-year, $212.4MM extension in July. This did not check in as a top-market deal, but it landed in the upper reaches of QB money. This came after a report surfaced indicating the Dolphins were not prepared to go into the Jared Goff–Trevor Lawrence range for Tua. His Week 2 scramble that led to a concussion brought calls for retirement, but with the fifth-year player now cleared, retirement would deny him access to the bulk of the mega-deal he recently signed.
In terms of the Dolphins’ 2024 prospects, this is massive news. After finishing second in scoring last season, McDaniel’s offense has plummeted to 32nd. The team has started both Skylar Thompson and Tyler Huntley, with neither playing well, and Tim Boyle — who failed to stick with the Texans in training camp after the Jets had released him in-season last year — saw action as well. These QBs restrained Miami’s speed armada on offense, as the team slunk to 2-4.
The Dolphins will need to heat up in a hurry to have a realistic chance of returning to the playoffs for a third straight season, but Tagovailoa will provide a fighting chance. He will not use a Guardian Cap upon returning, and how Miami goes about protecting its centerpiece player will be a key storyline to monitor as he returns to action.
