JANUARY 1, 2023: David Newton of ESPN.com hears from multiple executives that Darnold is playing himself into a short-term deal worth between $10MM-$12MM per year. Though Carolina’s difficult salary cap situation will be an obvious factor in its quarterback plans this offseason, Newton expects the club to have interest in a reunion if the price is right. Presumably, that would not preclude using a high draft choice on a collegiate passer.
DECEMBER 25, 2022: The 2022 season has seen plenty of turbulence for the Panthers with a coaching change taking place and the team being wrought with uncertainty at the quarterback position. The encouraging play from the team under interim head coach Steve Wilks is unlikely to change their aggressiveness in finding a long-term signal-caller in the coming offseason, though.
Carolina entered this spring with Sam Darnold under contract on his fifth-year option, but they were widely expected to add at the position after the former first-rounder’s underwhelming performance in 2021. That resulted in an active pursuit of Deshaun Watson, though the maligned passer was wary of Matt Rhule‘s uncertain future with the organization. Those concerns proved to be well-placed, as the latter was fired five weeks into the campaign, one which started off in disastrous fashion for the Panthers’ offense in particular.
That brought on criticism for Baker Mayfield, who had been under center for each of those games. Acquired in July from the Browns long after the Panthers’ interest in him became clear, the former No. 1 pick struggled mightily in his first year in Charlotte. That resulted in his being benched for XFL alum P.J. Walker, and – after Darnold’s return from a preseason ankle sprain – dropped to third place on the depth chart.
In a relatively unsurprising move, Mayfield was waived just under three weeks ago, which led to a season-ending starting role for him with the Rams. Darnold, meanwhile, has served as the Panthers’ starter in each of the past four games, a stretch which has included three wins to give the team a chance of winning the NFC South. The potential for a strong finish from the USC alum could lead to a deal keeping him in Carolina, but a new quarterback is still expected to be acquired soon.
ESPN’s Jeremy Fowler and Dan Graziano report that owner David Tepper is thought to be eyeing a move which “solve[s] his quarterback room once and for all.” That likely would not entail a long-term extension for Darnold, and 2021 third-rounder Matt Corral has missed his entire rookie campaign due to a Lisfranc injury. The Ole Miss product will therefore be expected to fill in strictly as a backup in 2023, regardless of who emerges as the starter.
With Carolina currently projected to be in a worse cap situation than most in the upcoming offseason, the draft represents the obvious avenue for the team to add a new No. 1 QB. However, Fowler and Graziano’s colleague David Newton notes that Darnold’s play could “open the possibility” the Panthers at least wait until after the first round of April’s draft to select a signal-caller. Carolina’s Day 2 and 3 set of picks was bolstered midseason by the Christian McCaffrey trade, giving them plenty of options with respect to adding at least another developmental passer.
The failed experiment with Mayfield is simply the latest in a long line of moves the Panthers have made in recent years which underline their need for a long-term solution under center. The spring of 2023 will represent another opportunity to solve the issue, with the team’s decision regarding retaining or replacing Wilks likely to have a significant impact on their plans.
The crystal ball is strong.
Ryan Tannehill or Derek Carr
too good?
OK fine, Marcus Mariota should do the trick
Water is wet
The Force is strong with that franchise as well as the owner
Hello Zach Wilson
This would be a typical stunned Panthers move. When a top two pick Jets QB trade fails, repeat.
Come on! Give Corral a shot.
The sun is hot
You know that Baker Mayfield is looking pretty good in L.A. …..
Oh Wait………..
Looks like he wasn’t the problem…..give him a competent coach and the guy can play QB in the league. Mcadoo is trash.
Depends on what games you watched. He looked good in his first game. Bad in his 2nd game and really good in his 3rd game. Kinda sounds like his career.
2nd game was lambeau in freezing temps. Even rodgers who is used to playing there didn’t have a great game. Try again.
Look at his overall numbers. He was not really good in Cleveland. Brissett had better numbers than Mayfield. Mayfield will have a good game and then a really bad game. Rodgers won back to back MVP playing at Lambeau. Judging by your username, you’re President of the Baker Mayfield is the GOAT fan club. You and 3 members. Baker is below average
he’s doing OK. not good.
I could see them overpaying for Jimmy G
DUH
If they win the division that’ll likely take them out of drafting one. Might have to sign another stopgap or trade for a vet
Daniel Jones would be a good choice — Carolina is getting it done with another ex-New York QB.
Tepper is too erratic and impatient to be an effective owner. Until the Panthers achieve some stability in the FO and coaching ranks, the approach behind center will continue to be plug and play.
Right now the bigger worry for the Panthers is finding a way to poach the NFC South. As long as they avoid defeat at Tampa, it’ll be decided in Week 18. Lose to the Buccaneers and Carolina is done.
I haven’t really paid attention to them lately, are they winning IN SPITE of Darnold?
In the combined 34 seconds of Panthers’ highlights I’ve seen the past few weeks, he’s looked good.
address their QB situation through the draft?
nothing says let’s settle our QB position than a starter and backup with no NFL game experience
A grumblings and a rumblings in Baltimore. Lamar unhappy? Wants out? A real topic of talk locally. Send to Panthers for their 1st and 2nd in 23 draft and 1st in 24? Ravens trade up in 23 if need be to get the Alabama QB, B. Young?
2nd move. UFA Darnold better than Huntley? If so, ink him for a couple years until Young takes over.
The Ravens would have to give up everything they get from the Panthers to move up enough to draft Young.
#Deerhunter; good point. That said; Houston is looking for a QB. Lamar for their 1 which is the overall 1 in 23?
Baltimore would want more based on what the others have gotten. I don’t think Houston wants a veteran quarterback. They need to build up their roster
I don’t think that Huntley’s effectiveness is what would separate him from a potential replacement. Unless Baltimore is prepared to change their carefully constructed offensive identity, the issue for any potential replacement is his ability to run that offense moreso than his per se effectiveness as a quarterback entirely.
Liked, “carefully constructed offensive identity” So true!
Given the fact that half the league can’t find a true franchise QB it would seem like adopting a strategy that doesn’t require one would work better in the long run.
Since the Browns are now presumably locked into their QB of choice for a long, expensive time, have the Panthers inherited the “quarterback roulette” trophy?
Mark Davis: “Nobody told me there was a QB roulette trophy…now I really need to trade Derek Carr”.
Since trophies HAVE to be named, who should we name this dubious honor after? The Jimmy Haslam trophy?
I’d say Tepper Trophy. Carolina keeps changing quarterbacks mid season for the last few. Browns have only changed quarterbacks once in 5 years
Wonder if Trey Lance could be a target. Brock Purdy has been really good in SF. If he gets them to the SB even wins it Trey Lance could be out.
Outside of Garapollo the free agent qbs aren’t all that note worthy.
I hear Baker Mayfield will be available.
This is so silly. Carolina’s problem is they can’t commit to a quarterback in the first place.
Mason Rudolph will be available. He’s awful, but he will be available.
Rudolph’s rowdy win ugly style would suit the Panthers perfectly.
The sky is also blue.
No shite
Surely Darnold deserves another look after how he is playing out the end of this season. Spend the spare money/draft picks on offensive linemen. Correl can enjoy another development year or two since he was out this year.
Or is QB roulette the game in Caroline, not football?
new coach, new staff,new qb, more secondary help=good offseason